Check My ZIP
Menu
Home › Comparisons › GEICO vs Allstate

GEICO vs Allstate: which is cheaper in 2026?

DW By Dana Whitfield · Reviewed by the BudgetAutoRates editorial team Updated July 2026 620 matched quote pairs
Billie's Verdict: GEICO

For pure price, GEICO wins in 41 of 50 states, averaging $16/mo less on comparable full coverage. Pick Allstate if you want a local agent and smoother claims: it beats GEICO on claims satisfaction three years running.

Head to head

CategoryGEICOAllstateEdge
Avg liability / mo$45$61GEICO
Avg full coverage / mo$133$149GEICO
Teen driver added cost+$148/mo+$176/moGEICO
Rate after one at-fault accident+42%+31%Allstate
Claims satisfaction (J.D. Power)871889Allstate
Discount programs1619Allstate
Mobile app rating4.84.3GEICO
Local agentsNo10,000+Allstate

Sample data for layout purposes. Production numbers come from matched-quote sampling plus public J.D. Power and NAIC data, per the methodology page.

Pick GEICO if · Pick Allstate if

GEICO fits you when

  • Price is the whole decision
  • You manage everything in an app
  • You're insuring a teen driver

Allstate fits you when

  • You want a human agent in town
  • Claims experience matters more than $16/mo
  • You'll bundle home + auto for its bigger multi-policy cut

Neither might be your cheapest. Billie grazes across 100+ carriers.

See My Real Rates

Common questions

Why is GEICO usually cheaper than Allstate?

No agent network to pay for. GEICO sells direct, and roughly 10% of every Allstate premium goes to distribution costs GEICO doesn't carry.

Which one raises rates more after an accident?

GEICO jumps about 42%, Allstate about 31%. Billie's take: the teaser rate is just the appetizer.